Permanently Deleted
:FrogPog: Frog man bad
Claiming there is no narrative is, in fact, a narrative.
Been re-watching LOTR and the fact that everyone “good” is white is obviously problematic.
Doesn’t mean I don’t cry every time when Theoden does his speech in ROTK and they ride down to the Pellanor screaming “DEATH”
Only vaguely related but “Death of the Author”, even if it is the title of an old book, is such a ridicoulusly pretentious term for a really quite simple concept that it genuinely makes me cringe to say it.
Convincing people that words don’t actually mean anything is how capitalists keep the workers from understanding dialectical materialism.
:jesse-wtf:
I agreed with your OP but now I feel like you’re going off the rails. Show don’t tell is fundamental writing advice and I don’t understand how it’s supposed to be anti-communist. Fictional works obviously contain many different messages which can be meaningful and worth analyzing regardless of whether or not they’re intentional.
It sounds more like you had a teacher who either didn’t understand the material or was bad at teaching it, than a problem with “show, don’t tell” or encouraging people to draw their own (informed) conclusions, which are both good things.
I’m well aware lol. Just started reading Grundrisse and the forward by Martin Nicolaus makes this exact point (using mainly citations from Lenin’s Philosophical Notebooks). The Hegalian method relies heavily on language and terms that might seem superfluous on first glance but actually hold a lot of meaning. Like the concept of “suspension” which if read uncritically is meaningless, but in the context of the dialectic, is super powerful because of it’s double meaning of both ceasing movement and also maintaining the process of movement.
All meaning comes from some form of contradiction and if you only ever see one side of the contradiction, you haven’t really seen anything.
