Hexbear

1 point

4 years ago

Isn’t what is not objective stuff like: whether the LDB became the Archmage of Winterhold, or became the leader of the companions? Stuff like the existence of Altmer, the LDB beating Alduin are 100% objective, no?

report

CrookedSerpent [she/her]@hexbear.netOP

[ - ]

4 points

4 years ago

Not really. The games are just representations of the actual TES universe, weather the protagonists did particular quests, what race and gender they were, is left vague. Like obviously whiterun isn’t 15 huts in universe, 90% of the population isnt bandits, and so on.

report

[ - ]

1 point

4 years ago

Stuff like the existence of Altmer, the LDB beating Alduin are 100% objective, no?

Are the existence of high elves not objective?

report

CrookedSerpent [she/her]@hexbear.netOP

[ - ]

2 points

4 years ago

In a sense, no, just as we could say the existence of birds is not 100% a given IRL. But, for the sake of communication, in real life and in TES it is safe to make assumptions about such things. But really, if you really care about 100% canonical constancy, than TES probably isn’t for you.

report

[ - ]

2 points

4 years ago

I don’t care about 100% consistency; I’ve admitted that stuff like Archmage of Winterhold is left up in the air. There has to be a baseline consistency though, otherwise the universe would just be a nonsensical mess.

report

CrookedSerpent [she/her]@hexbear.netOP

[ - ]

5 points

4 years ago

It is a nonsensical mess. :yes-chad:

report

[ - ]

2 points

4 years ago

Earlier you said to another commenter:

No, the dunmer’s skin was turned to ash (blueish-gray, and thier original skin color was gold-brown) for the tribunal’s betrayal of Azura at red Mountain (a volcano). Azura’s actions are not good (she is known for being venguful when slighted), the deities of TES are not the arbiters of morality in this universe, this is not in anyway an association of black skin with evil.

The elder scrolls universe isn’t a nonsensical mess because a certain baseline consistency is established. We both believe the dunmer exist, we both believe deities are not the arbiters of morality in the universe, we both acknowledge that dragonrend cannot be used by dragons. Even the soul as dragon thing you believe in is at least metaphorically sound. We aren’t sitting here claiming that Nazeem single-handedly defeated Alduin at the Soul Cairn because such a claim would be so far off the base establishment.

report