I have somehow met a vegan CHUD and they’re convinced an ancap vegan society is possible

You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments
Removed by mod
permalink
report
reply
4 points

in order to enable sustainable meat-based diets requires some out of the box thinking.

Disregard all of this if you were, in fact, suggesting plant-based meat-based diets.

.

Why are you talking about the sustainability of omnivorous diets as an objective for out-of-the-box thinking in a vegan community? It reads as a tacit endorsement of carnism, and therefore omni apologia and advocating violence against animals; both of which are against the rules of this community.

It doesn’t matter whether omnivorous diets are sustainable or not. That point is a more peripheral concern to the concern that meat-based diets are categorically unethical and evil, besides the situations wherein we need to caveat and prioritise a basic and acceptable quality of life and/or our survival.

You should be wanting the exact opposite of “enabling [sustainable] meat-based diets”. “Sustainable” and “meat-based” (= conscientious omnivorism) should be A) inherently contradictory, besides the fact that B) it’s unsustainable.

A) Endorsement of a meat-based diet is in direct contradiction with our high regard for sustainability.

I remind you that the reason we care about the environment is that sentient animals, including ourselves, live within it. The biotic community- the entire ecological community - is not important without the necessary ingredient of sentience. You should first and foremost care for the environment only insofar the reason that sentient beings live within the environment, and that the environment gives us the inexplicable value of the life that lives. In this way, our value for self and other is foundational for our high regard for the environment. (As an aside, sentience outside of the animal kingdom is plausible, but that’s a different discussion.) I remind you of this, because your high regard for sustainability seems divorced from the understanding that the reason we value the environment is because there is something foundational we value in it.

As an aside, not that I believe the next part, as that would be uncharitable, but the only way for a high regard for sustainability to be compatible with endorsing meat-based diets is if you had an anthropocentric or selfish world view that only benefitted your in-group (excluding non-human animals and additionally not including all humans), or that only benefitted yourself.

B) You can’t get sustainable omnivorism. That’s a discussion for another time, if it even needs discussing.

tl;dr: Enabling sustainable meat-based diets is missing the point. It’s like endorsing welfarism instead of abolitionism in a vegan community.

permalink
report
parent
reply
Removed by mod
permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points
*

I’m sorry for misunderstanding.

Can I ask though, did I read your non-veganism correctly? Your point about enabling sustainable meat-based diets seemed inherently non-vegan to me, which I wouldn’t expect to see from a vegan.

permalink
report
parent
reply

vegan

!vegan@hexbear.net

Create post

:vegan-liberation:

Welcome to /c/vegan and congratulations on your first steps toward overcoming liberalism and ascending to true leftist moral superiority.

Rules

  • No plant-based diet bullshit or promotion of plant-based capitalism. Veganism isn’t about you, it’s about historical materialist anti-speciesism, anti-racist animalization, and animal liberation. Ethical vegans only.
  • No omni apologists or carnists. Babystepping is for libs, and we’re not here to pat you on the back. Good faith questions and debate about how to fight for animal liberation are allowed.
  • No advocating violence to any species for any reason. If you think this is negotiable GTFO. This includes but is not limited to animal testing, slaughter, and mass euthanasia. Anything that promotes speciesism or the commodification of animals will be removed.
  • Use Content Warnings and NSFW tags for triggering content. Especially if a comrade requests it.
  • Questions about diet belong in c/food. It’s also a great place to share recipes.
  • In all sections of the site, you must follow the Hexbear.net Code of Conduct.

Resources

Animal liberation and direct action

Read theory, libs

Vegan 101 & FAQs

If you have any great resources or theory you think belong in this sidebar, please message one of the comm's mods

Take B12. :vegan-edge:

Community stats

  • 3

    Monthly active users

  • 877

    Posts

  • 8.7K

    Comments