Comment by Guildo@lemmygrad.ml on What if I told you Israel doesn’t have a right to exist

The state is necessary until the elimination of class. Only then will the state wither away. The concept of a state is necessary but progress can only be had with a socialist state and not a capitalist state.

Also Israel is a lynchpin for imperialism in the Middle East. It actively runs intelligence, disruption and assassination programs. Mossad is essentially The CIA’s middle eastern branch. The destruction of Israel is a major blow to imperialism.

Please stop criticizing any state until you have the power to abolish it.

I don’t think I will

And now explain me how you will change anything about if, if you don’t have the power in your state.

Knowing is half the battle

I disagree, just because our goal is a stateless world doesn’t mean states that actually represent their population (e.g. AES countries) have no right to exist

You didn’t understand it, comrade. If you’re saying Israel has no right to exist your focus is not on point. Why do you have the urge to mock about Israel all time? It’s a waste of time. It’s the job of the citizens of Israel to do a revolution, not yours. Your job is to start a revolution in your state. You’re wasting time and resources. You can mock about Israel, if you have the power in your state, but not now.

Please read up on international solidarity. I also have to ask, are you Anti-Deutsche?

Then go to Palestine and fight on the side of Fatah. In which way are you doing your part in international solidarity? Are you doing practical work or are u just using words? I bet you’re just using words. Using words is nothing.

So we shouldn’t be saying anything about anything ever if we don’t have the capabilities right this moment to do something about it?

Are you aware how much BDS has done to damage the Israeli regime over the last few decades? So much so Israel wants them banned worldwide for it. Bringing the abuses of the Israeli regime to light and telling people what they can do to damage Israel by boycotting their products for example are very real, material things people can do. It’s not going to save Palestine by itself, but it helps them.

+ I would rather fight for Hamas, Fatah are collaborators. I really have to wonder if you’re not a supporter of Israel now.

BDS ist “Konsumkritik” like we say in germany. It’s the bullshit anarchists are promoting. If you really wanna do something you start a revolution. What do you wanna do next, not buying at Amazon to make Jeff Bezos suffer? I bet he starts crying, if you stop buying at Amazon. If you really want to change sth. you have to start organizing people and seize the means of production. And where do you start with it? In the state you’re living in. Start a revolution, bro and stop trying to reform capitalism.

Actually the only reason Isreal can exists is US connections. So working here for them is part of the struggle

Yeah, I’ll wait till this really happens. You can remind me anytime. Till then everything we’re talking about this is a waste of time. The imperialists and capitalists in your country are laughing about us.

Waste your time, go for it, but I work on organizing my people.

I haven’t mentioned “Israel”, but claiming that I can’t mock or criticize another state because I live in a capitalist country is bizarre

it’s not like any other state, it’s a settler colony actively committing genocide, which is only true for a few other states

And now explain me how you will change anything about if, if you don’t have the power in your state.

The “people” of Israel don’t want revolution because they love the benefits their Fascist state propped up by the US gives them.

if you have the power in your state

I live in the US. I don’t have the power to do anything here, or even start a revolution (you think FBI wouldn’t wipe out anyone who tried?)

That’s why we have a problem.

All states are not the same. Flattening the world into “all states are equally bad” is kiddy shit.

What’s really funny is that below they were claiming that BDS is “anarchist shit”, lol.

Why are you posting on this site? You’re supposed to be organizing!!! Why are you criticizing others’ words? You should be organizing!!!

Good memes, bad memes, unite towards a united front.

What if I told you Israel doesn’t have a right to exist(lemmygrad.ml)

Memes

!memes@lemmygrad.ml

Community stats

Community moderators