34 points

I distinctly remember every course teaching proper use of citations back in that decade saying Wikipedia is a trash source and you should at best use it to get acquainted with a subject you have no knowledge in. Also, “pretty early days” doing a lot of heavy lifting there since it was founded in 2001. It was 10th busiest in the world by 2007 (source: Wikipedia article “History of Wikipedia” (lol)).

permalink
report
reply

2009 was so late in wikipedia history that not on had every field (and subfield) made their own specialized wikipedia pages, many of them had started dying off at that point lol. Also that was a fun experiment that I wish hadn’t died. I found the specialized wikis (which had proper authorship and some peer review) to be more useful than published literature reviews as a grad student. Scholarpedia pages are still up and probably useful, but I doubt many have been touched since 2012. Might be fun to run random matlab and python code from there just to see how compatible it still is lol.

permalink
report
parent
reply

the amount of math topics covered in some detail on wikipedia is genuinely sort of staggering.

permalink
report
parent
reply
15 points

I just wish their math articles were more comprehensible to normie dummies like me

permalink
report
parent
reply

Bruh, that’s not the excuse you think it is.

🤓 “Akshually, that specific website was not listed in the academic integrity policy so it’s okay”

permalink
report
reply

Lol what’s this about?

permalink
report
reply
38 points
*

Harvard president had plagiarism allegations against her, he was particularly vocal about it. A business insider journo went through his wife’s doctoral dissertation and found like 30 instances of plagiarism, including 15 instanced of entire paragraphs being copied straight from wikipedia.

It didn’t look like the plagiarism was really particularly meaningful, like it wasn’t original ideas just like lifting some historic summaries. But it’s still pretty problematic. And I’m gonna guess that the Harvard president case is similar, mostly just filler.

Oh he’s had multiple meltdowns about this, not obvious from the screenshot but his tweets on this are well over a page long

permalink
report
parent
reply

Lmao thats hilarious.

I just looked him up, he sounds like the worst kind of person ever. Ugh.

permalink
report
parent
reply
19 points

In 2009 I already knew better than to copy from Wikipedia without changing the wording a little, no excuse for being dumber than a middle schooler.

permalink
report
reply
18 points

you cant use ANY encyclopedia you fucking clown

permalink
report
reply