Avatar

daxattack [none/use name]

daxattack@hexbear.net
Joined
0 posts • 75 comments
Direct message

Those are good points. I do think the youth doesn’t have the sentimental attachment to the USSR that older Ukrainians would have. It sounds absurd but from what I hear from my Belarusian cousins they are jealous of Poland for being in the EU and they’d prefer to join the EU if it meant giving up their Russian ties. It’s probably similar to how lots of Scottish and Welsh people feel about England.

I guess my main issue with the “they couldn’t possibly side with Europe over Russia because they’re ethnically Russian” is that if Luka were to ever be overthrown by a pro-EU government in Belarus I know my cousins would love that and like most Belarusians they grew up speaking Russian. Many on this site would say that was a CIA plot or that they are brainwashed by Western propaganda but idk their economic outlook is generally pretty shitty over there. One of my cousins made it over here to the US from Belarus and loves it here compared with back home.

People aren’t necessarily 100% loyal to the country that aligns with their ethnicity or native language, that doesn’t really make sense. It wouldn’t surprise me if lots of Ukrainians disliked Yanukovych without the CIA brainwashing them into doing so since it’s probably similar to how plenty of Belarusians hate Luka in a similar way.

permalink
report
parent
reply

I agree that Ukraine is very corrupt and not “fighting for democracy” or whatever the Western media is saying about this war, but is there any chance that Ukrainians wanted to push toward the EU and away from Russia’s economic influence? It’s always taken at face value that the Euromaidan protests were US backed and the protestors were all US/NATO puppets, but what if many of them just didn’t want to be another Russian puppet state like Belarus and wanted to try to increase their standard of living? Not saying I agree with them, both options of moving forward are shitty but the “Russia was provoked” argument only works if the Ukrainians had no autonomy whatsoever and were being controlled by the CIA like puppets.

Otherwise it’s much less justified if Ukraine just wanted to move away from Russia’s influence toward the West on its own accord. Having millennial cousins over in Belarus who hate Luka I wouldn’t be surprised if most millennials in Ukraine truly just opposed Russia and wanted to move away before the invasion. Eastern Ukraine and Crimea is a different situation as that part of the country was much more sympathetic toward Russia but I don’t get why Putin didn’t just ramp up the fighting against separatists there instead of push to Kyiv? Once he brought the invasion to the entirety of Ukraine it can only be justified if he was provoked beyond belief, not just a regional conflict.

I get we are propagandized to an absurd degree in the West but I feel like lots of users here swing too far the other way. I don’t think NATO is as smart as lots of people here might think, Ukrainians wanting to move toward Europe is not even considered as a possibility which seems at the very least to be intellectually dishonest.

permalink
report
parent
reply

According to my Indian-American buddy his Hindutva cousins love Putin and hate the “d3generate” Ukrainians. Very odd massive movement but yeah the invasion has a lot of Hindu nationalist support

permalink
report
parent
reply

So in your view Putin is a rational leader and the “good guy” and Ukrainians are the bad guys for defending their country? I understand the ongoing conflict in eastern Ukraine starting in 2014 (was bubbling up even before then) but just want to understand how you see things so black and white that way. Are Putin’s stances on gay and trans people pure Western propaganda? Because what I’ve seen him supposedly say is not good to say the least. But maybe I’m just fully propagandized

permalink
report
parent
reply

I agree the quotes sound like Hitler talking about the Jews, it is genocidal rhetoric. Weirdly enough it doesn’t seem like Trump truly hates trans people and he’s even defended them in the past but if the party wanted him to sign a bill ordering the liquidation of all trans people of course he’d do so without hesitation since he doesn’t really have any principles himself. I do think there is a small portion of Democrats who do truly care about trans rights and aren’t just paying lip service but as a whole I get what you’re saying. Thanks for the insights

permalink
report
parent
reply

I get all of that but that doesn’t square with this:

I agree with your friends on the harm reduction nonsense to the extent that I even wonder if more harm has come about under Biden than would have under Trump

I asked one of my friends again who is worse on trans rights Trump or DeSantis and they said Meatball Ron truly wants trans people to no longer exist. Biden himself seems fairly pro-trans rights so even if the Dems suck ass as a whole the guy who literally hates the community is probably more of a threat? I don’t get the opposition toward the harm reduction vote for Sleepy Joe angle. They sent me more stuff DeSantis has said and it’s really next level hate damn.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Thanks I thought it might be around then and there. Very fucked up. Russia has obviously killed far more civilians at this point but I understand the opposite was the case prior to the invasion

permalink
report
parent
reply

How does he pack the SC lol the senate is still useless and they’d have to be on board

permalink
report
parent
reply

I think that’s probably an overreaction compared to a genocide like the Holocaust. All of my leftist friends say voting for Biden/the Dems for “harm reduction” is a fruitless endeavor, if Trump/DeSantis were actually going to genocide the LGBT community I doubt they’d say that since it wouldn’t be very pragmatic. I think both parties are fairly similar in terms of working for capital first and foremost

permalink
report
parent
reply