Permanently Deleted
You start from material reality just as all the other anarchists/Marxists have before you.
I don’t care about your opinion on other countries.
Put your revolutionary theory into practice and produce a successful revolution. Hell if you do it without authoritarianism I’ll become a /c/ProductiveForces-ism over night and I’ll be in nonstop contact trying to tease out exactly how you produced this revolution so I could hopefully follow your path
I have faith in you to blaze this trail and lead the tankies out of the dark, confused muddle we’ve been in since 1991
The material reality is that your authoritarian ideas about socialism dont work. Are you going to call Venezuela, China, DPRK or Ussr socialist states that are run by THE PROLETARIAT
The material reality is that your authoritarian ideas about socialism dont work.
Do you know what “material reality” means? Because by definition they exist so they do obviously work.
Anarchism has never existed in material reality except in the form of the Dictatorship of the Proletariat (That’s not a criticism, it’s the correct revolutionary path) except they named the DOTP to something like “The Anarchist Regional Revolutionary Council” because anarchists think when they change the names of things they change the things themselves (which are just as authoritarian as anything tankies do: Anarchists outlaw newspapers not owned by them, have a monopoly on violence, secret police, smmary executiosn of counter revolutionaries, a penal system etc.)
But you hold the correct revolutionary ideas so produce a revolution in your own country then we can talk
