I think this disingenuously conflates two separate ideas: is it ok to have and state preferences about the kind of bodies you’re attracted to, and whether you’re doing so in a neutral way or a cruel, bullying way.

You’re probably right about that, but I do also think that it’s worth interrogating in ourselves why we find certain types of bodies attractive, and what types of people we find attractive or not, and why. That is actually something I try to think about on my own time, and it’s something that I do try to make concessions about in as much as I’m capable.

It’s worth noting, that I don’t think women would do this out of any kind of ill-will, really. Certainly not in the same way that my hypothetical dude would be. I highly doubt that they actually know exactly what a “6 foot” guy actually looks like anyways (in the sense that I don’t think most people could eyeball that as a precise measurement). The point is that they would want a guy who’s noticeably taller than both themselves & other men around them. And the question is like “Why; where exactly is that desire coming from?”

And I imagine if you really dug into it it’s more than just a personal preference. :shrug-outta-hecks:

Or rather that there are specific reasons for those preferences that would be surprisingly gender-essentialist, and those probably ought to be challenged.

It seems like you’re of the opinion people aren’t allowed to be attracted to certain things and not others…

My take is that I don’t necessarily care if any particular person has a specific set of preferences with regards to who they like to hang out with, or what they’re attracted to.

However it’s very difficult to disentangle broad social trends about those things, from the manifest reality of social hierarchies between people, & social discrimination between types of people. Which isn’t just about targeting people for abuse & mistreatment btw, it’s also about leaving them isolated, or without a community.

In effect I do think that both men & women can reproduce patriarchal standards (and also other kinds, not just those specifically) through who they choose to associate with. And for that reason it’s worth being at least mildly skeptical of, and pressing people a little bit to explain why they “like what they like”.

I think the thing you’re missing is men swipe left all the time based on weight, or breast size, or just closeness to whatever standard of beauty they have. The difference is most of these apps are photo-based, so there’s no need to explicitly specify those preferences. Height, on the other hand, is quite hard to determine by looking at photos a person has selected, so if it’s important to someone they have every right to state that.

That’s a fair point & counterargument. I suppose that it is true that they would do that, and that this isn’t really something that is easily questioned, or discouraged within the framework of dating apps. I would say that this is a reason why dating apps are in general, probably bad.